Church of England
The Man Who LaughsThe Church of England is presented as the established Episcopalian institution whose public advantages coexist with private religious dissent. Through Josiana’s concealed Catholic faith and outward Protestant conformity, the novel portrays religious allegiance as entangled with rank and social advantage, while its wider reflections on repentance and conscience place moral judgment beyond institutional affiliation alone.
Identity and Public Position
The novel identifies the Church of England with official Episcopalian worship and the benefits attached to public conformity. Its account of Josiana makes that position concrete: she is secretly Catholic among trusted associates but outwardly Protestant, maintaining the public identity that protects her standing. The contrast depicts the Church less through its organization or doctrine than through the social function of belonging to the established confession.
The surrounding account places religion within a sharply ranked political order. It presents English usage as addressing God with a title associated with human lordship, alongside claims that a lord is nearly a king and a king nearly a god. This juxtaposition links sacred language to earthly hierarchy; it does not, however, describe the Church of England as administering that hierarchy or its punishments.
Josiana and Confessional Conformity
Josiana’s religious position is shaped by her family and by the risks of public allegiance. The narrator associates her private Catholicism with her uncle, Charles II, rather than her father, James II, whose Catholicism cost him the crown. Josiana, by contrast, does not risk her peerage: she remains publicly Protestant while keeping her Catholic identity within a narrower circle.
The narration treats this division between private conviction and public profession satirically. It describes the established church’s advantages as available to someone who conforms outwardly, while imagining Catholic observance at death as a separate, later possibility. The point is not that Josiana formally changes churches, but that her religious presentation can shift according to audience and circumstance. In her case, confession is shown as both personal affiliation and a calculation made under the pressure of social position.
Religion, Authority, and Conscience
The Church of England belongs to a broader portrait of Restoration-era public order in which monarchy, social rank, and accepted cultural standards are represented as restored together. The same passage praises the return of political order while placing Dryden above Shakespeare, making the period’s official judgments about government and literature part of one satirical picture. The passage does not attribute these judgments directly to the Church, but it situates established religion within a culture that treats conformity as part of social order.
Elsewhere, the novel gives repentance and conscience a reach that is not confined to a named institution. In a crisis at sea, a speaker urges the guilty to seek salvation, regret their crime, and pray; the narration then reflects on the fear and religious belief of the dying. At dawn, conscience is figured as something reawakened by light, with Christ or Love offered as names for a moral summons. These passages make religious responsibility a matter of inward reckoning as well as public affiliation, without identifying the Church of England as the source of the appeal.
Narrative Significance
The Church’s most specific significance lies in the contrast between its public authority and Josiana’s private practice. Her outward Protestantism secures the social identity she is unwilling to put at risk, while her concealed Catholicism exposes the difference between profession and conviction. Set against the novel’s recurring association of divine language with human rank, that contrast makes established religion part of a wider examination of how power and status shape public belief. The text’s emphasis on repentance and conscience, meanwhile, leaves ultimate moral accountability larger than the performance of religious conformity.
